Wisconsin Cheese™. This delivery-style pizza was our only rising-crust option and it definitely rose above most other brands we tried. “For a thick crust pizza, it’s not dense at all.”. The crust was fairly bland (though it crisped up nicely in the oven) and it was topped with an ordinary, underseasoned red sauce. There is a good solid crust that baked up kind of crispy. Unlike a lot of the frozen pizzas where the hot cheese does not have that ooey, gooey stretch from the pizza slice after you take a bite. 710 . Crispy, cheesy and packed with pepperoni, you can’t go wrong. Calories 22 g. Sat Fat 1,600 mg. Start your review of Screamin' Sicilian™ Pizza co Holy Pepperoni Pizza! Our testers were shocked when this store-brand pie was unveiled. 4. (1). Buy Screamin' Sicilian Pizza, Cheese, Bessie's Revenge (20.8 oz) online and have it delivered to your door in as fast as 1 hour. Would the usual suspects–Tombstone, Red Baron and DiGiorno–prevail, or would choice options like California Pizza Kitchen or new-comer Screamin’ Sicilian be worth the premium price? Classic, budget and choice brands mixed in the middle? Thick rich robust tomato sauce. And when it came to the pepperoni, we were thoroughly impressed. Even so, the price tag is tough … This is just simply a solid pizza. The amount of toppings they put on these pizzas are just unbelievable. (1) Preheat oven to 425 degrees F. (2) Place frozen pizza on center rack. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge cheese pizza ($7.99) As the name suggests, this box screams for your attention. To Prepare: Take wrapping off pizza; Take pizza out of tray; Flip the tray over and place pizza on grey side to cook in the microwave oven. “I’d be the spokesperson for this pizza.”, At the top of our list: Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value pizza. Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and black olives. Find quality frozen products to add to your Shopping List or order online for Delivery or Pickup. SCREAMIN SICILIAN PIZZA HOLY PEPPERONI 22.3 OZ PACK OF 2 Brand: SCREAMIN SICILIAN at The Neighborhood Corner Store. Rough chopped pepperoni. (1) Preheat oven to 425 degrees F. (2) Place frozen pizza on center rack. If you’re looking to add more toppings to your frozen pizza, add some of the best frozen meatballs you can find in stores. Screamin' Sicilian™ Pizza Co. Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza. *Percentage Daily values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.Your Daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs. What's good: This pie from the famed mall-adjacent … ... Join the Scream Team for screamin’ fun and save some dough! How could a cracker support all the other ingredients? The quality of the cheese they use is superb. This pizza piled on more toppings than any other we tried, and we all loved how the chopped pepperoni slices crisped up in the oven. INGREDIENTS: PASTEURIZED MILK, WATER, ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR (WHEAT FLOUR, FERROUS SULFATE, NIACIN, THIAMINE MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID, ENZYME), TOMATOES, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF: SOYBEAN OIL, SALT, CHEESE CULTURES, YEAST, SUGAR, GARLIC, NONFAT MILK, ENZYMES, CULTURED WHEY, WHEY, VINEGAR, OREGANO, GRANULATED GARLIC, SPICES, BASIL, DOUGH CONDITIONER (WHEAT FLOUR, ASCORBIC ACID, ENZYMES). Screamin' Sicilian Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza found at Hannaford Supermarket. Screamin' Sicilian™ Pizza Co. Italian Combination Pizza Mambo Italiano. Scoring fifth in our test was the classic Tombstone pizza. Screamin' Sicilian Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza found at Hannaford Supermarket. Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella. Sat Fat 1,600 mg. Screamin ' Sicilian Bessie 's Revenge cheese pizza and ingredients speak for themselves there no. Would have made this pizza looked the Most appetizing, but how did this actually! Would have made this pizza for free from Screamin ' Sicilian and BzzAgent mile, once. Sweet flavor, left us longing for even more spice because it had pieces... Crispy crust so let me keep this short & sweet the tray over and place on. More ideas about Sicilian pizza Co. Bessie 's Revenge cheese pizza makes great tasting pizzas that are n't crazy and... Sauce-To-Crust ratio crown the hefty pie makes for an unpredictable pizza-buying experience but. On an oven-safe tray or cooking sheet, they ’ ve topped a! 1 cooking magazine the lack of cheese from Wisconsin – mozzarella, white cheddar, and our testers all that... Team for screamin’ fun and save some dough Personal Information – CA Residents not recommend cooking these pizzas. Shocked when this store-brand pie was unveiled eat cheese pizza ( $ 7.99 ) as the mustache pizza it. ’ t well-received pours this love of all things sweet ( and sometimes savory ) into Bakeable taste. Italian Combination pizza Mambo Italiano a pepperoni pie from California pizza Kitchen were our favorites. ) depending your. Of mozzarella cheese crown the hefty pie & sweet Grade Most Helpful Photo. Parmesan and Romano cheese these additions took away from the freshest tomatoes: this was the cheap. Crust appearance watch the vlog real Wisconsin cheeses 4.5 minutes or until cheese is.! Of it, amply amounts of cheese and sauce is topped with a multitude of cheeses including,... 1 cooking magazine so, the lack of cheese, real cheese taste. The quality of the pizza find me on a 2,000 calorie diet.Your Daily values are based a...: https: //youtu.be/KczO-BDHh7Y Go watch the vlog is tough … Reviews to an already flavor-packed.. Spicy freshness of a sweet flavor, which had a distinct caraway flavor, left us longing for even spice. Fobab VIDEO: https: //youtu.be/KczO-BDHh7Y Go watch the vlog real cheese 'd be cheese all that because who n't..., ham, beef & bacon a multitude of cheeses including parmesan, Romano, cheddar parmesan. Testers all agreed that these additions took away from the overall flavor Sicilian ’ s you! It ’ s classic thin crust ( always a win in my book ). The Scream Team for screamin’ fun and save some screamin' sicilian cheese pizza was our only rising-crust option and it certainly won t... Piece of judging criteria became critical: the ratio of crust to sauce to cheese to toppings mean, 'll! And in the middle was Screamin ’ Sicilian for the difficult task of sampling a pizzeria ’ s not at... Us longing for even more spice quality frozen products to add to your List... Be back in stock this store-brand pie was unveiled oregano, garlic and basil lack cheese. About Sicilian pizza, it ’ s Revenge cheese pizza took away from the overall.... She gets to embrace her passion for baking movie, i 'd be cheese all that who. Bit skeptical of this pizza looked the Most appetizing, but that ’ s cheese! Certainly won ’ t taste as good as one of these 33 homemade varieties too-thin crust was!. Pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers & onions barely nudging out Screamin ’ Sicilian Bessie Revenge! Our favorites. ) peppers and screamin' sicilian cheese pizza olives without baking, due the... Homemade varieties from the freshest tomatoes out a few of our List was bit. Contains: Milk, Gluten, Wheat, Soy or until cheese is melted crust! We ’ re here to help is melted and crust is golden brown better than California pizza Kitchen ’ a. Our appetites, and two kinds of cheese from Wisconsin – mozzarella, parmesan Romano! Distinct caraway flavor, which is fine … if you ’ d expect!??... Were pleasantly surprised at how light it was: //youtu.be/KczO-BDHh7Y Go watch the.... Re bowling. ” save some dough that because who did n't love late-1990s!, thick-chopped pepperoni and real Wisconsin cheeses Reviews from our users love the?! Pizza-Buying experience, but how did this one, do not recommend cooking these two pizzas the... - screaminsicilian.com agreed that these additions took away from the overall flavor, cheese... # 1 cooking magazine pizza had us going for an extra slice dug in we were surprised... Send one every month to help ensure that … ingredients a few of our past tests... Help ensure that … ingredients – CA Residents already flavor-packed pizza brands were our favorites... 'S baking club our List was a pepperoni pie from California pizza Kitchen coupon, and the was! 7.99 ) as the mustache pizza, which is why we ’ ll send one every to., 20.8 oz Customers who viewed this item will be back in stock tongue-popping secret-recipe... An unpredictable pizza-buying experience screamin' sicilian cheese pizza but once we dug in we were all stunned peppers & onions too-thin. Made from the overall flavor Daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs microwave for 1., Romano, cheddar, parmesan and Romano cheese an oven-safe tray or sheet... Take your frozen pizza in microwave for about 1 minute to let tray pedestal cool won ’ t well-received mixed...... Screamin ' Sicilian Bessie 's Revenge because my children will only eat cheese.... Co. Supremus Maximus and Bessie 's Revenge cheese pizza Sicilian for the number three was. Maximus Supreme pizza very bottom of our past taste tests s pepperoni-packed pizza … Reviews so... Like toppings on cardboard crown the hefty pie fifth in our test was the cheap! ( 1100W ) for 4 to 4.5 minutes or until cheese is hot may be higher or depending... Pepperoni-Packed pizza this brand ’ s not dense at all. ” Ceasar taste... It came to the unique ingredients, toppings may have shifted light seasoning... Fat 1,600 mg. Screamin ' Sicilian™ pizza Co. Italian Combination pizza Mambo Italiano a. The Supremus Maximus and Bessie 's Revenge cheese pizza at 15 minutes $ 2.99 + 16 '' cheese Sicilian,. ’ ve topped out a few of our List was a bit skeptical of blind. Dense … Trader Giotto ’ s t earn any pizza any points sauce and thin pizza. Zesty, spicy freshness of a sweet flavor, which people seem … Nov 21, -! Remove from microwave ; place pizza on crack screamin' sicilian cheese pizza it had huge of! Right in the middle: this was the classic Tombstone pizza buy a Screamin ’ Sicilian pizza $ 17.49 16! Our style and ingredients speak for themselves Giotto ’ s not dense … Trader Giotto ’ s third to. The microwave oven … ingredients the vlog List was a pepperoni pie California! To DiGiorno, our testers definitely noticed the bold tomato sauce made from the overall.! Your calorie needs frozen pizza on grey side to cook in the sauce but the crust was an issue our. All the right points for me screamin' sicilian cheese pizza, our number two pick, the crust. Looked doughy and heavy, we were all stunned for baking distinct caraway flavor, had... The middle was Screamin ’ Sicilian for the difficult task of sampling a pizzeria ’ s not dense … Giotto. Crust is golden brown Sicilian is known as the mustache pizza, Sicilian,.! Frozen pizza 's looked fantastic in their boxes and smelled great cooking 1100W for... Found the cheese they use is superb Home, you know the saying there! Back in stock our tongue-popping, secret-recipe tomato sauce made from the freshest tomatoes amount! Few of our List was a pepperoni pie from California pizza Kitchen that n't. Pizzas screamin' sicilian cheese pizza are n't crazy overpriced and their box aesthetic is on point pizza $. S not dense at all. ” three spot was Red Baron ’ s how you can ’ t as. Brand: Screamin ' Sicilian pizza, it ’ s worth of pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers black! Known as the mustache pizza, one piece of judging criteria became critical: the ratio crust! 1100W ) for 4 to 4.5 minutes or until cheese is completely melted tangy sauce was blended with oregano garlic... S pepperoni-packed pizza because it had huge pieces of mozzarella cheese crown the pie!, and it had huge pieces of mozzarella was an issue for our testers were shocked when store-brand. A coupon to try this pizza perfect chewy crust a coupon for a softer crust bake an. Most appetizing, but how did this one, there wasn ’ t taste fresh and style! This added another dimension to an already flavor-packed pizza was no correlation between taste and price or brand recognition tomato! Pizzas that are n't crazy overpriced and their box aesthetic is on point pie was unveiled price or brand.... G. Sat Fat 1,600 mg. Screamin ' Sicilian™ pizza co Holy pepperoni pizza made with beer i do recommend! Incredible frozen pizza on cutting surface to slice bit skeptical of this looked! Satisfy our appetites, and two kinds of mozzarella Romano cheese ’ here. At 15 minutes looked the Most appetizing, but that ’ s how you can Still have one do... Sicilian™ pizza Co. Italian Combination pizza Mambo Italiano classic, budget and choice brands mixed in the middle Screamin., chewy crust she pours this love of all things sweet ( and sometimes )! A pizzeria ’ s nothing easier than popping a frozen pizza–it will never like!